What is a home equity investment?
A home equity investment, also sold as a home equity agreement or shared equity agreement, gives a homeowner an upfront cash payment in exchange for a lump sum later that is based partly on the home's value.[1] There is no monthly payment. You repay by the end of the term, usually 10 to 30 years, or earlier on a trigger such as selling the home, defaulting on a senior lien, not paying property taxes or insurance, or the owner's death, and partial payments are generally not allowed.[1]
The company records a lien on the home just as a mortgage lender does, and a homeowner who cannot pay the full settlement at the end risks having to sell or facing foreclosure.[1] Washington's financial regulator found the contracts are almost always secured by a deed of trust on the owner's primary residence.[2] Companies often market them as "not a loan" with "no interest"; the CFPB's review measured what they cost as a rate anyway.[1]
| Home equity investment | Home equity loan or HELOC | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | None | Yes (interest-only on many HELOCs during the draw) |
| What you repay | A share of the home's value (or of its change), up to any cap | What you borrowed plus interest |
| When | End of term (often 10–30 years) or on sale or default | Over the loan term |
| Cost if the home gains value | Rises with the home | Set by the rate |
| Secured by the home | Yes, a lien | Yes, a lien |
How the payoff is calculated
Every company's formula uses the cash paid, the starting and ending home values and a multiplier.[1] Some apply the multiplier to the home's whole value, others to the change in value, and many lower the starting value with a "risk adjustment", for example setting it 25% below the appraisal.[1][2] The CFPB's example pays 10% of the home's value and takes back the lesser of 20% of the value at settlement (a 2× multiplier) or a capped amount.[1]
Investor stake (share of value) = multiplier × cash ÷ starting value2 × $50,000 ÷ $500,000 = 20%
Payoff = stake × home value at settlement, up to the cap20% × $895,424 = $179,085
Yearly cost = (payoff ÷ cash received)1 ÷ years − 1($179,085 ÷ $44,000)1/10 − 1 = 15.07%
The cash received is after fees. Processing fees are often 3% to 5% of the payment, plus appraisal and recording fees; in the CFPB's example a 4% transaction fee and $2,000 of third-party fees cut $50,000 to $44,000.[1] The calculator's yearly cost uses that net figure, so it is higher than a rate on the full $50,000.
A share-of-the-change contract works differently: you repay the cash plus a share of the gain above a discounted starting value. The CFPB's example of that type is a 40% share of the change with the starting value cut by 30%.[1] On the same home at 6% a year for 10 years, with no cap, that contract would settle at $268,170, or 19.81% a year on the cash received.
The cap and the early years
Several companies cap the cost at around 18–20% compounded monthly, so the settlement amount cannot grow faster than about 19.5–22% a year.[1] Without the cap, the CFPB found, the projected repayment on day one would be 25% to 100% more than the cash the homeowner received; with it, the amount grows at 19.5–22% a year in the early years under many contracts.[1] That is why settling early is expensive: in the example the cap decides the year-3 payoff of $86,400 (20% a year), while by year 10 the share of value, $179,085, is below the cap (15.1% a year on the cash after fees).
| Value change a year | Year 3 | Year 5 | Year 10 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0% | $86,400 (cap) | $100,000 | $100,000 |
| -2% | $86,400 (cap) | $90,392 | $81,707 |
| +3% | $86,400 (cap) | $115,927 | $134,392 |
| +6% | $86,400 (cap) | $124,416 (cap) | $179,085 |
The CFPB's own scenarios put the year-10 repayment between $94,074 and $215,892 on $50,000, and in its 6% scenario the homeowner owes $86,400 in year 3 and $179,085 in year 10, the same figures the calculator gives.[1] Over the long run home prices have changed between −5.6% and 16.8% a year, about 5% on average, by FHFA data cited in the report.[1]
Home equity investment vs. a HELOC
The CFPB compared the same $50,000 drawn on a HELOC at 9%, interest-only: $375 a month, $95,000 over 10 years in interest plus repaying the balance. The home equity contract cost less only if the home lost at least 5% of its value over those 10 years.[1] The calculator's loan line is a stricter yardstick: it lets the loan's interest compound with nothing paid, the closest a loan comes to a contract with no monthly payments. At 9% that owes $122,568 after 10 years, $56,517 less than the contract's $179,085.
A HELOC or loan needs monthly payments and income to qualify; a home equity investment does not, which is the reason people use one. Before signing, compare the payoff at several home values and exit years, and check what a home equity loan or HELOC would cost on the HELOC calculator. To see how much equity you have to work with, use how much equity do I have in my home.
Your home secures itThe settlement is due in one payment. If you cannot pay it from savings or a refinance when the term ends, you may have to sell the home. Read the contract's triggers, the cap, the starting value it uses and every fee.
What to check in a home equity sharing agreement
- The starting value. A discounted starting value raises your stake or the gain the investor shares in.[1]
- The multiplier or share. Enter it above with the cash offered to see the payoff at several home values.
- The cap. Some contracts limit the total settlement; others have no limit.[1]
- Fees. Fees taken from the payment raise the true yearly cost.[1]
- Ongoing costs. You still pay property taxes, insurance and any other debt on the home, and all costs of selling it.[1]
- Disclosures. Companies use non-standardized disclosures, so the cost is not shown as an APR.[1]
A future mortgage can be affected too: on loans Fannie Mae buys, an agreement to pay a third party a share of the property's appreciation is not permitted as subordinate financing, except under its Community Seconds program.[3]
Frequently asked questions
How does a home equity investment work?
You get cash now and repay one lump sum later, usually within 10 to 30 years or when you sell, based on the home's value at that time. There are no monthly payments, and the company holds a lien on the home.[1]
How much does a home equity investment cost?
It depends on what the home does. In the CFPB's example, $50,000 on a $500,000 home costs $179,085 after 10 years at 6% growth, and the year-10 range across its scenarios was $94,074 to $215,892.[1]
Is a home equity investment a loan?
What happens if my home loses value?
On a share-of-value contract you repay less. In the CFPB's comparison the contract beat a 9% interest-only HELOC over 10 years only when the home lost at least 5% of its value.[1]
Can I pay a home equity investment off early?
Usually only in full, since partial payments are generally not allowed, and early settlement is when the cap makes the yearly cost highest.[1]
Is any of it tax deductible?
There is no interest payment to deduct each year. Mortgage interest rules in IRS Publication 936 apply to loans secured by the home; ask a tax professional how a settlement is treated.[4]