Piggyback loan: 80/10/10 vs. one loan with PMI

A piggyback loan is a second mortgage taken with the first so the main loan stays at 80% of the price and needs no PMI. On a $400,000 home with 10% down, the 80/10/10 split costs $2,549.14 a month against $2,571.74 for one loan with PMI; over 7 years the piggyback costs $10,979 less.

Calculator

Piggyback loan calculator

An 80% first mortgage plus a second, against one loan with PMI

The purchase

$
%
years

Piggyback

%
%
years
%
years

One loan with PMI

%
%
Piggyback monthly payment$2,549.14$2,152.66 first + $396.48 second
One loan with PMI$2,571.74$2,421.74 + $150.00 PMI
Cost over 7 yearsPiggyback$10,979 less
PMI ends9 yr 9 mowhen the balance reaches 78% of the price
Amount borrowed$360,000
First mortgage (80% of price) at 7.11%$320,000
Second mortgage at 8.61%$40,000
Combined loan-to-value90.0%
Piggyback cost over 7 years$173,735
One loan + PMI cost over 7 years$184,715

Cost = payments made + balances still owed − amount borrowed, so both options are compared on the same money.

Cost by how long you keep the loans
YearsPiggybackOne loan + PMICheaper
3$77,025$81,034Piggyback
5$126,348$133,574Piggyback
7$173,735$184,715Piggyback
10$240,478$257,878Piggyback
15$336,711$361,063Piggyback
30$486,324$529,377Piggyback

How it is calculated. First mortgage = price × first share; second = price − down payment − first. Each payment = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)−n). One loan = price − down payment; PMI = loan × PMI rate ÷ 12 until the scheduled balance reaches 78% of the price. Cost over the period = payments + PMI + balances still owed − amount borrowed, so both options are measured on the same money.

On this page
  1. What is a piggyback loan?
  2. Why 80%: the mortgage insurance line
  3. Piggyback vs. PMI: which costs less?
  4. Piggyback by down payment
  5. FAQ
  6. Sources

What is a piggyback loan?

A piggyback loan is a second mortgage or home equity line made at the same time as your main mortgage, so you can qualify for the main loan without paying for private mortgage insurance. The CFPB's example is a 10 percent down payment, an 80 percent main mortgage and a 10 percent piggyback, the 80/10/10 structure.[1] It notes the second "typically carries a higher interest rate, which is also often adjustable," that piggybacks were common in the early to mid-2000s and are rare today, and that refinancing later needs the second lender's agreement.[1]

$400,000 home with 10% down: how the money is split
Piggyback (80/10/10)One loan with PMI
Down payment$40,000$40,000
First mortgage$320,000 (80%)$360,000 (90%)
Second mortgage$40,000 (10%)–
Mortgage insuranceNone on the first$150.00 a month until month 117
Monthly payment$2,549.14$2,571.74

Why 80%: the mortgage insurance line

The 80% split exists because of mortgage insurance. Fannie Mae's charter bars it from buying a conventional mortgage above 80% of the property's value unless the part above 80% is insured, the seller keeps a participation, or the seller agrees to repurchase,[2] and its Selling Guide requires primary mortgage insurance on a first mortgage with an LTV above 80% unless another allowed credit enhancement is used.[3] A second loan that keeps the first at 80% avoids that requirement on the first.

The second still counts toward the combined loan-to-value: CLTV adds the first mortgage, the drawn part of a HELOC and any closed-end second, divided by the lesser of the price or appraised value.[4] On a standard Fannie Mae purchase of a one-unit home you live in, the maximum LTV/CLTV is 97% for a fixed-rate loan and 95% for an ARM.[6] Fannie Mae also requires a second to have payments that at least cover its interest, and does not accept one with a balloon due less than five years after the new first mortgage.[5]

Piggyback vs. PMI: which costs less?

Which is cheaper depends mostly on the second loan's rate and on how long you keep the loans, because PMI ends while the second keeps charging interest. Under the Homeowners Protection Act, PMI ends automatically when the balance is first scheduled to reach 78% of the original value, and you can ask to cancel at 80%.[7] In the example PMI would end after 117 months (9.8 years).

Cost over the period = payments + PMI + balances still owed − amount borrowedpiggyback $173,735 vs. one loan $184,715 over 7 years

Cost over time: $360,000 borrowed, second at 8.61%, PMI 0.5% a year
Years keptPiggybackOne loan + PMICheaper
3$77,025$81,034Piggyback
5$126,348$133,574Piggyback
7$173,735$184,715Piggyback
10$240,478$257,878Piggyback
15$336,711$361,063Piggyback
30$486,324$529,377Piggyback

The CFPB's advice is to ask for a quote on the same loan as a single loan with mortgage insurance and compare total costs.[1] Enter both quotes above. Run the PMI side alone on the PMI calculator, and see when it can come off with the PMI removal calculator.

Piggyback by down payment

The smaller the down payment, the larger the second loan and the more its rate matters. With the same rates as above:

$400,000 home: piggyback and one loan by down payment (cost over 7 years)
Down paymentSecond loanPiggyback monthlyOne loan + PMI monthlyCheaper over the period
5%$60,000$2,747.38$2,714.62Piggyback by $10,869
10%$40,000$2,549.14$2,571.74Piggyback by $10,979
15%$20,000$2,350.90$2,428.87Piggyback by $10,665

A second with an adjustable rate can move like a HELOC; check its rate cap and see how a payment changes with the index on the HELOC calculator. To test whether the total payment fits your income, use how much house can I afford.

TaxesInterest on a second mortgage used to buy your home counts as home acquisition debt, within the same $750,000 limit as the first. The itemized deduction for mortgage insurance premiums had expired for 2025 returns. Check IRS Publication 936 for your year.

Those two points come from IRS Publication 936.[8] The first-mortgage rate in the example is the Freddie Mac 30-year average of 7.11% for the week of Nov 12, 2026;[9] the second-loan and PMI rates are illustrations, so replace them with your quotes.

Frequently asked questions

What is an 80/10/10 loan?

An 80% first mortgage, a 10% second mortgage (the piggyback) and a 10% down payment, the structure in the CFPB's example.[1]

Is a piggyback loan cheaper than PMI?

Sometimes. It depends on the second's rate and how long you keep the loans, because PMI ends at 78% of the original value while the second keeps charging interest. In the example, over 7 years the piggyback costs $10,979 less.[7]

Why do piggyback loans stop at 80%?

Fannie Mae cannot buy a conventional loan above 80% of value without mortgage insurance or another credit enhancement, so a first mortgage at 80% needs none.[2][3]

Are piggyback loans still available?

The CFPB says they were common in the early to mid-2000s and are rare today but could return.[1]

Can I refinance a piggyback loan?

Yes, but the CFPB notes the second lender has to agree to a refinance of the first, which can make it harder.[1]

Sources

  1. What is a "piggyback" second mortgage? · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, last modified September 13, 2024 (read from the Internet Archive copy captured June 7, 2026)
  2. 12 U.S.C. § 1717(b)(2), Fannie Mae purchase limits above 80% of value · U.S. Code, 2023 edition (govinfo), 2023 edition
  3. Selling Guide B7-1-01, Provision of Mortgage Insurance · Fannie Mae, April 2, 2025
  4. B2-1.2-02, Combined Loan-to-Value (CLTV) Ratios (Selling Guide) · Fannie Mae, December 4, 2018
  5. Selling Guide B2-1.2-04, Subordinate Financing · Fannie Mae, August 6, 2025
  6. Eligibility Matrix (Selling Guide) · Fannie Mae, August 5, 2026 (read from the Internet Archive copy captured October 31, 2026)
  7. Homeowners Protection Act, 12 U.S.C. § 4902 (cancellation and termination of private mortgage insurance) · U.S. Code, 2024 edition (govinfo), 2024 edition
  8. Publication 936 (2025), Home Mortgage Interest Deduction · Internal Revenue Service, for 2025 returns, reviewed April 30, 2026
  9. Primary Mortgage Market Survey (PMMS) · Freddie Mac, week of November 12, 2026